Best Crib Mattresses: Cradle Comfort

Overwhelmed with the entry of an angel in your life…welcome to the new life of parenthood! Yes…it is time to relive your childhood with those little nappies and rumbling rattles. And as much as you enjoy shopping for those zero size jumpsuits and mittens, remember that it is only two places where your little angel finds beatitude-either in your arms or on that super cozy crib mattress that recreates the warmth of your cuddle. So, think beyond the world of blue and pink and use the prudence of a parent while you go shopping for the best crib mattress.

Now, wondering what prudence to use in buying the a crib mattress?

All that one would look for is softness and comfort…well unfortunately the task is not that simple as it sounds. Firstly, it is not only about softness and comfort but also about the quintessential security. Secondly, remember you are laying a foundation for a sound sleep habit that shall lasts all through your child’s life…surely you would not want to go wrong and finally, you are buying for an end user for whom you need to feel and understand the experience for he can only cry to express and not speak out.

So, to help you face this new challenge of parenthood, we bring to you this detailed review that gives you an insight about everything you wanted to know about crib mattresses.

Factors to consider when choosing the best Crib Mattress

The infant years are the most important years of your child, especially while he is sleeping. For most of the growth of a baby occurs during his sleep. So to make this experience of sleeping healthy and meaningful, you need to keep the following factors in mind while choosing a crib mattress.

  • Size of the mattress: Look out for a bespoke mattress that just fits into your child’s crib. Any unwanted gaps or space left in the crib can intrude security leaving you with the fear of suffocating or dangerously trapping your child..
  • Resilient to movement: Your infant is like a rolling pin that never sits or sleeps still in the crib. Moreover with growing years the movements increase too. Therefore, choose a mattress that generously encompasses the movements of your little angel with every passing growth stage.
  • Firmness: Yes, this factor is important for crib mattresses too. To develop good growths in a child ensure that the crib mattress is firm. This provides good support to the growing body parts and helps them to align naturally.
  • Density: Density and firmness are correlated factors. Choose a crib mattress that displays a good proportion of both.
  • Air flow: A crib mattress with good air flow not only regulates the temperature of the bedding but also keeps away foul and unnatural odors that can easily disturb your child’s blissful sleep.
  • Water Resistance: If you are a fresh parent then no one knows this better than you that a water resistant crib mattress is the ultimate factor which you should look for in that small bedding frame. It not only keeps your child’s mattress free from bacterial growth that might develop from your leaking babies, but are also easy to remove and clean.

5 Best Crib Mattresses

Let us take you through the top 5 contenders in the best Crib Mattress segment.


Special Features



Colgate Eco Classica III

Dual sided firmness, organic cover

10 pounds

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

Foam mattress, light weight, eco-friendly

10.3 pounds

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core

Innerspring mattress, very light weight

8.3 pounds

Naturepedic No Compromise

Dual side mattress, eco-friendly, organic

30 pounds

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams

Light weight, affordable, water resistant

8 pounds

Now let's review each of them in detail.

#1 - Colgate Eco Classica III Mattress

best crib mattress

A best seller from the team of Atlanta based Mattress Company who has been specializing in mattresses for infants and toddlers. A dual firmness mattress with double sides and GREENGUARD certification that is designed to last from infancy till the time your little angel grows up to be toddler. The infant side of the mattress offers good firmness, whereas the other side is a bit soft and is recommended for toddlers. A lightweight mattress with an organic cover and water resistant encasing with absolutely no odor to disturb your little one during sleep.

  • Eco-friendly mattress with plant based oils
  • Odorless
  • Extremely lightweight
  • Dual firmness sides
  • GREENGUARD Certification
  • Cleaning and maintenance is easy
  • Rounded edges in places of squared
  • Difficulty in removing stains

Our Verdict

When it comes from one of the most trusted brands in the segment, you expect nothing but the best. A strong combination of firmness and comfort, the mattress can lasts for almost five years from the time you welcome your little one till you see him change into a toddler. Just change sides of the mattress and make the most of your money.

#2 - Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Mattress

best crib mattress

An ultimate foam crib mattress which is also endowed with the goodness of two types of firmness-one for infants and the other for toddlers. Despite being a foam mattress at the core it is free of vinyl, polyethylene, PVC, phthalates and lead. With drop side-stitched seams the mattress has beautiful snug fit in the crib leaving no scope for gaps and spaces.

Being a foam mattress it is extremely light and users especially appreciate the ease they experience in changing sheets. An extremely eco-friendly product made of a water resistant material that is non-toxic. A simple product that is likely to attract its users with its feel and comfort that they would appreciate more than its fancy design at this stage.

  • Lightweight
  • Dual side firmness
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Affordable
  • No toxic material used
  • Ease of cleaning
  • Some parents complained of its over firmness

Our Verdict

A durable product that literally lasts from the cradle to the toddler’s bed. Eco-friendly qualities are worth attracting the prospective buyers and the price also fits in your budget as coolly as the mattress fits in the crib. A class product that meets all security standards and promises a safe and healthy sleep to your little one. It is one of the best crib mattresses out there.

#3 - Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress

A star product from an award winning company that delivers quality with safety. Unlike other contemporary mattresses discussed so far, this mattress does not have dual firmness sides but its one side is firm enough to provide good support to your baby. With a GreenGuard Gold certification its quality is well tested and authenticated.

The mattress has a high density core and a pearl embossed cover which is not only water resistant but also stain proof. The mattress comes with a squared corner design that fits perfectly into the bed frame of your infant. An ultimate eco-friendly product that is made up of renewable soybean foam that is completely organic.

  • Eco-friendly soybean composition
  • Water resistant and stain proof
  • Squared edges with good fit
  • No odor
  • No heat retention
  • Some users found it too firm
  • Noisy with baby turns

Our Verdict

A true value for money that has high security standards and meets them with grace. An eco-friendly product made of renewable soybean core that gives you all reasons to choose this product. However, a little creaky noise when your baby turns may put him off but soon it fades away with more usage.

#4 - Naturepedic No Compromise Mattress

A 100% organic product that completely wins over the hearts of users looking out for cent percent natural products. Like most of the other mattresses on the list, it is a dual firmness mattress suited for both the cradle and the toddler’s bed. An award winning product that has won accolades for its performance in the field of comfort, firmness, security, natural and healthy sleep. A water resistant mattress with good edge support and made of 100% organic material.

Though the mattress comes for a reasonably good price, it is surely the quality for which you pay the extra bucks. A hands-on winner in terms of health and safety for your little one that impresses every crib mattress buyer.

  • No harmful chemicals used
  • 100% organic
  • Allergen friendly
  • Waterproof
  • Good air flow that maintains breathability
  • Dual firmness sides
  • Slightly heavy as compared to other contemporary mattress
  • Price range is higher

Our Verdict

No doubt the product is highly priced as compared to its counterparts, but it is a true value for money in its real sense. For all the extra bucks that you pay, you get quality, health, comfort and safety of your little one. No doubt the mattress is also heavy in terms of weight but then every good thing has a downside, and so does this. Loaded with so many benefits this mattress is a must for you if you prioritize health over your expenditure.

#5 - Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress

A decent foam mattress especially good for those who are on a look out for budget mattress. Fits into almost all standard sized bedding frames for kids, this mattress too has loads of qualities. A good comfortable mattress with a touch of firmness that retains its shape even after years of usage. However, made of polyurethane foam, it is something that may discourage you from using it for your kids. But remember, it has multiple other benefits that negate this shortcoming. The outer cover of the mattress is made of water resistant material and comes in a convenient zip case that can be easily removed and washed.

The mattress offers ideal support to your baby helping him grow with every dose of sleep. The mattress also has good edge support that is maintained even when it is shifted to a toddler’s bed.

Being a lightweight mattress, it is very easy to change sheets, pull it out of the crib for cleaning or to carry it during travel. With good heat regulation, the mattress has a quick cooling property despite being a foam mattress.

  • Lightweight
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Affordable
  • Easy to clean
  • Waterproof
  • Heat resistant
  • Good edge support
  • Not dual sided like other mattresses
  • At times noisy with baby movements

Our Verdict

An all in all affordable product that offers good support and comfort. With a water resistant cover and zip encasing, it is one of the most convenient crib mattress to use and maintain. With good durability, satisfactory performance and affordability it stands a good chance to impress an average buyer who is not very demanding.

The Bottom Line

When it comes to your baby, you would want nothing but the best. While each of the mattresses reviewed above has some or the other outstanding feature, remember that all options in the market can be equally alluring. So use your best judgemental qualities and research capabilities before you go out shopping for your kid’s first crib mattress.

Look out for a mattress that has three main parameters to fulfill-comfort, firmness and safety. All other star attractions are only the icing on the cake, which may add value to your purchase but are just secondary. These three qualities go a long way in defining the true mettle of your buy.

Moreover, while you may focus on long term durability to stretch its use to the toddler bed, remember that it is not only your first purchase of a crib mattress but also the foundation of a sound sleeping habit. Try not to save any pennies here or make any cheap bargains. Quality comes at a price… and accept it.

The above review just aims to unfold before you the little secrets of crib mattresses to make your shopping experience a comfortable one which not only leaves your baby smiling in the cradle but also brings a charming smile on your face when you see your little heart lost in his dreamy slumber land. Happy baby…Happy Mamma! Hope you find the best crib mattress for your baby.

Leave a Comment: